Why Beth Phoenix Deserved More Than She Received at the End
Posted: Nov 6th 2012 By: mikeiles
In a backstage segment shorter than most commercial breaks, Vickie Guerrero fired "The Glamazon" Beth Phoenix, writing the last chapter of Phoenix's WWE career.
As WWE's best female wrestler for much of her tenure with the company, she deserved more than that for her farewell.
Being written out of Raw is expected, but not in a way that felt so much like an afterthought.
No one is confusing Phoenix for Shawn Michaels or Ric Flair, so going out at WrestleMania was never an option, but there had to be a way to honor her work with something a little more grand, something more significant.
She didn't even put over a young star on her way out.
Informed fans knew of Phoenix's impending departure long before it happened. Wrestlinginc.com reported that Phoenix would be leaving the company in October and retiring from wrestling. Word got out.
No one can blame her for wanting to leave.
Did Phoenix Just Lose Her Smile?
How can you keep your passion for pro wrestling after being asked to lose to Nikki Bella, to hold the Divas title but rarely defend it at pay-per-views, to constantly be underutilized?
Phoenix spent much of her time with WWE being the relief pitcher in the bullpen who is only asked to throw to one hitter every eight games. They treated her like a marginal talent at times.
In a pre-WrestleMania Twitter rant, Phoenix tweeted:
"I'm sick of being pushed aside and forgotten about. I am the Divas Champion and I get ZERO respect. I should be featured in magazines, being a guest star. The entire WWE has it all backwards."
Maybe this was strictly meant to hype up her match with Maria Menounos, but it wouldn't have taken much imagination on Phoenix's part to come up with these thoughts.
Yes, they put several championships around her waist, but they also gave those titles little importance. When CM Punk began his "don't disrespect me" campaign, Phoenix should have been screaming right alongside him.
Not that WWE disrespecting women wrestlers comes as a surprise.
Regardless of their in-ring ability, WWE's Divas are rarely given more than a few minutes to perform. They rarely get any significant storylines to enhance their matches.
These kinds of frustrations had Gail Kim desperate to leave the company.
Aside from a paycheck, what was Phoenix's incentive to stick around? She was never going to get anywhere near her full potential there.
Missed Opportunities
According to an interview on diva-dirt.com, Natalya and Phoenix had been petitioning for the first-ever WWE Divas ladder match.
WWE never let them make that piece of history.
Phoenix proved how spectacular she could be with the aid of a ladder when she faced Katie Lea in a ladder match for the Ohio Valley Wrestling Women?s Championship on Dec. 13, 2006. She never got to recreate that magic in WWE.
The tail end of Phoenix's WWE run was rife with missed opportunities.
She could have been what Chyna was to the Attitude Era, but so much more. Why didn't she have a long, bitter feud with Natalya where they put on great match after great match?
Why was she missing from WWE programming as much as she was?
Phoenix's bio will read well: second woman ever to compete in the Royal Rumble, three-time Women's Champ, one-time Divas champ.
That info belies the fact that WWE had a spectacular wrestler on its roster who it flat out wasted in the last years of her tenure. It's only fitting that her exit from the company would be so underwhelming.
WWE poked holes in her a long time ago and the last of the air finally wheezed out.
Phoenix deserved so much more. If fans are lucky, she'll change her mind about retirement and find a wrestling home elsewhere.
Supplemental Information
Latest News
AEW starts new collaboration in support of Rebel
AEW continues to prove its love and support for Rebel. Upper Deck and AEW are coming together in a new collaboration to... Read More
The Scoop
NEWS Mick Foley posted on his Instagram stories that he was “so excited for and proud” to be part of Wednesday night’s “AEW Dynamite - Rebel Hear... Read More
AJ Styles on retirement, matches with Cena and Gunther, his son, and more
AJ Styles sat down with Chris Van Vliet in Nashville, Tennessee to discuss his retirement match w... Read More
- Ethan Page talks NXT, move to main roster, working with Chelsea Green, The Rock, and more
- WWE SmackDown Comes to OKC: Royce Keys talks Royal Rumble debut
- Jeff Jarrett talks relationship with Dixie Carter, Dark Side of the Ring, TNA, and more
- Carlito talks departing WWE, time in Judgment Day, Bron Breakker spear, and more
Spotlight in History
- 1967 Brute Bernard def. Bull Curry for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 1974 Jose Lothario def. El Gran Markus for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 1987 Eric Embry became the WCCW World Light Heavyweight Champion
- 2008 Dustin Heritage def. Kenny Campbell for the IZW Impact Division Title
- 2008 Impact, Inc. (Johnny Z & Bernie D) def. Nathan Sensation & Striker for the IZW Tag Team Titles
- 2008 Shawn Sanders def. Kevin Morgan for the OECW Heavyweight Title
- 2008 Martin Justice became the OECW Southwestern Champion
- 2009 3rd Rail def. Maniac Mike for the SWCW Hardcore Title
- 2009 Maniac Mike became the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 2014 J. R. Orullian & Running Wolf became the NAW Tag Team Champions
- 2014 The Trenchcoat Mafia (Ryan Reed & Billy Ray [1st]) def. J. R. Orullian & Running Wolf for the NAW Tag Team Titles
- 2014 The Trenchcoat Mafia (Ryan Reed & Running Wolf) became the NAW Tag Team Champions
- 2020 Dimitri Alexandrov def. O’Brien for the ASP Heavyweight Title
- 2025 Michael H became the NAW Openweight Champion
- 2025 Jupiter Jones def. Frankie Lee for the RDW Iron Man Title
- 2025 Sgt. Hartman def. Floyd Maystorm for the WAH Hunger Dojo Title
- 2025 Floyd Maystorm def. Sgt. Hartman for the WAH Hunger Dojo Title
Week of Sun 09-13 to Sat: 09-19
- 09-13 1967 Brute Bernard def. Bull Curry for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 09-13 1974 Jose Lothario def. El Gran Markus for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 09-13 1987 Eric Embry became the WCCW World Light Heavyweight Champion
- 09-13 2008 Dustin Heritage def. Kenny Campbell for the IZW Impact Division Title
- 09-13 2008 Impact, Inc. (Johnny Z & Bernie D) def. Nathan Sensation & Striker for the IZW Tag Team Titles
- 09-13 2008 Shawn Sanders def. Kevin Morgan for the OECW Heavyweight Title
- 09-13 2008 Martin Justice became the OECW Southwestern Champion
- 09-13 2009 3rd Rail def. Maniac Mike for the SWCW Hardcore Title
- 09-13 2009 Maniac Mike became the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 09-13 2014 J. R. Orullian & Running Wolf became the NAW Tag Team Champions
- 09-13 2014 The Trenchcoat Mafia (Ryan Reed & Billy Ray [1st]) def. J. R. Orullian & Running Wolf for the NAW Tag Team Titles
- 09-13 2014 The Trenchcoat Mafia (Ryan Reed & Running Wolf) became the NAW Tag Team Champions
- 09-13 2020 Dimitri Alexandrov def. O’Brien for the ASP Heavyweight Title
- 09-13 2025 Michael H became the NAW Openweight Champion
- 09-13 2025 Jupiter Jones def. Frankie Lee for the RDW Iron Man Title
- 09-13 2025 Sgt. Hartman def. Floyd Maystorm for the WAH Hunger Dojo Title
- 09-13 2025 Floyd Maystorm def. Sgt. Hartman for the WAH Hunger Dojo Title
- 09-14 2007 Dane Griffin def. Montego Seeka for the UWF06 Light Heavyweight Title
- 09-14 2007 Dane Griffin became the UWF06 Texhoma Champion
- 09-14 2013 Team Bull (The Bronze Bull & Bobby Starr) def. What Wrestling Should Be (Jermaine Johnson & Jordan Jacobs) for the IZW Tag Team Titles
- 09-14 2013 The Oakhurst Fire Mafia (Chief Mike & Keebler) def. The P. I. N. K. Nation (Ray Martinez & Tommy Toops) for the SRPW Tag Team Titles
- 09-14 2019 MVP def. Chavo Guerrero, Jr. for the WCR Heavyweight Title
- 09-14 2024 Original Renegade became the NAW Openweight Champion
- 09-14 2024 Umbra def. Trench Blythe for the WAH Spotlight Title
- 09-14 2024 Pastor Brent def. Daniel Aaron Michalles for the WAH Hunger Dojo Title
- 09-14 2024 Jean-Claude def. Eddie LeVaughn for the WAH Heavyweight Title
- 09-14 2024 Manico def. Billie the Kiid for the NAW Indigenous Land Title
- 09-14 2024 Jeb Bingham def. Jastin Taylor for the BCW Heavyweight Title
- 09-15 1969 The Medics (Medic #1 & Medic #2) def. Alberto Torres & Ramon Torres for the TSW United States Tag Team Titles
- 09-15 1980 Junkyard Dog & Terry Orndorff def. The Fabulous Freebirds (Terry Gordy & Buddy Roberts) for the MSW Mid-South Tag Team Titles
- 09-15 1986 Black Bart def. Chris Adams for the WCCW World Title
- 09-15 2007 Sudden Impact (Sudden Impact 1 & Sudden Impact 2) def. Texas, Inc. (Bernard Funk & Tim Rockwell) for the ComPro Tag Team Titles
- 09-15 2007 Anthony Jackson def. AWOL for the ComPro Heavyweight Title
- 09-15 2007 Shane Morbid def. Justin Lee for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Title
- 09-15 2012 Double D def. Aaron Neil for the IZW Heavyweight Title
- 09-15 2018 Chavo Guerrero, Jr. def. MVP for the WCR Heavyweight Title
- 09-15 2019 Chaz Sharpe def. James Southard for the ASP Inter-County Title
- 09-15 2023 Jastin Taylor def. Sam Stackhouse for the BCW Heavyweight Title
- 09-16 1975 John Tolos def. Al Madril for the WCCW Texas Heavyweight Title
- 09-16 1988 Michael Hayes & Steve Cox def. The Samoan SWAT Team (Fatu & Samu) for the WCCW World Tag Team Titles
- 09-16 2005 Lily McKenzie def. Chiquita Suzuki for the SRPW Womens Title
- 09-16 2006 Michael Barry def. Aaron Neil for the IZW Heavyweight Title
- 09-16 2006 Ryan Davidson became the IZW Impact Division Champion
- 09-16 2017 Paige Turner def. Erica for the IZW Womens Title
- 09-16 2017 Skyler Fayden def. Riker for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 09-16 2017 Big Smooth & Zakk Sinizter became the UWE Tag Team Champions
- 09-16 2022 Shane Taylor def. Johnny Bedlam for the TexPro Heavyweight Title
- 09-16 2023 Red James def. Ozzy Hendrix for the EPW Internet Television Title
- 09-17 1979 The Spoiler & Mark Lewin def. Kerry Von Erich & Bruiser Brody for the WCCW Texas Tag Team Titles
- 09-17 2004 Bobby Dalton def. Shane Morbid for the SRPW Hardcore Title
- 09-17 2008 Michael Faith became the TCB Heavyweight Champion
- 09-17 2008 High Society (Al Farat & Thomas Trump) became the TCB Dual Kombat Champion
- 09-17 2008 Michael Faith became the TCBW Heavyweight Champion
- 09-17 2008 High Society (Al Farat & Thomas Trump) became the TCBW Dual Kombat Champion
- 09-17 2010 Dane Griffin def. Cody Jones for the NWA-OK Texoma Title
- 09-17 2010 Aerial Assault (Ky-ote Joe & Montego Seeka) became the NWA-OK Oklahoma Tag Team Champions
- 09-17 2010 Michael Faith def. Dane Griffin for the NWA-OK Oklahoma Heavyweight Title
- 09-17 2016 Mr. Nasty def. Brian Breaker for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 09-18 1967 Chati Yokouchi & Togo Shikuma def. Danny Hodge & Skandar Akbar for the TSW United States Tag Team Titles
- 09-18 2005 Lance Cade & Trevor Murdoch def. The Hurricane & Rosey for the WWE RAW World Tag Team Titles
- 09-18 2005 Ric Flair def. Carlito for the WWE Intercontinental Title
- 09-18 2015 Sons of Texas (Moonshine Mantell & Killer McKenzie) def. The Imperialists (Charlie Haas & Griffin) for the NWA-TXO Tag Team Titles
- 09-18 2021 Thrash def. Jermaine Johnson for the WFC Hometown Heroes Title
- 09-18 2021 Reed def. Thrash for the WFC Hometown Heroes Title
- 09-18 2022 Fuel def. Koko for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 09-18 2022 Fuel def. Koko for the UWE Apex Title
- 09-19 1979 Mike Sharpe, Jr. def. Mike George for the MSW Mississippi Title
- 09-19 1982 David Von Erich def. Bill Irwin for the WCCW Texas Heavyweight Title
- 09-19 1988 The Samoan SWAT Team (Samu & Fatu) def. Michael Hayes & Steve Cox for the WCCW World Tag Team Titles
- 09-19 2014 Simply Irresistible (Matthew Palmer & James Johnson) def. The Dark Circle (Mace Malone & Apoc) for the NWA-TXO Tag Team Titles
- 09-19 2015 Loaded Guns (Jon Cross & Brandon Walker) def. The Rising (Riker & Abel) for the UWE Tag Team Titles
- 09-19 2015 Brian Breaker def. Clint Cassidy for the UWE United States Title
- 09-19 2015 Zakk Sinizter def. Anarchy [2nd] for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 09-19 2015 Jon Cross became the WFC Heavyweight Champion
- 09-19 2019 MVP became the WCR Imperial Champion
- 09-19 2020 Pastor Brent became the WAH Heavyweight Champion
- 09-19 2021 Maui Mike def. Thrash for the ASP Mid-American Title
- 09-19 2021 Brixton Barricade def. Brandon Barricade for the ASP All Time Title
- 09-19 2021 Malik Mayfield def. Jerome Daniel Griffey for the ASP Livestream Title
- 09-19 2021 Double D def. Jerome Daniel Griffey for the ASP 5-Star Title
- Angelina Love Sep 13th Today!
- K. P. Moore Sep 13th Today!
- Danny Little Bear Sep 13th Today!
- Bobby Starr Sep 13th Today!
- Poder Oriental Sep 13th Today!
- Waddy Young Sep 14th
- Kelsie Mae Sep 14th
- Eddie LeVaughn Sep 14th
- Lunatic Lennie Sep 14th
- Bernie D Sep 14th
- L. C. Green Sep 15th
- Korvin Sage Sep 15th
- Daniel King Sep 15th
- Spoiler 2000 Sep 15th
- Haru Sonada Sep 16th
- Colton Kinnamon Sep 17th
- Bill Irwin Sep 17th
- Jake Swayze Sep 17th
- Dick Brower Sep 17th
- Jim Cornette Sep 17th
- Rex Mori Sep 17th
- Cisco Grimaldi Sep 18th
- Angel Reed Sep 18th
- Billy Robinson Sep 18th
- Mr. Nabors Sep 18th
- Titan Yin Sep 18th
- Yoshiaki Yatsu Sep 19th
- Jerry Brisco Sep 19th
- Adam Asher Sep 19th
- Ethan Page Sep 20th
- Randy Rhodes Sep 20th
- Justin Lee Sep 20th
- Bishop Simon Sep 20th
- Boz Sep 20th
- Joey Stixx Sep 20th
- Greg Valentine Sep 20th
- Chuck Singer Sep 20th
- Pepper Martin Sep 20th
- Jack Brisco Sep 21st
- Ricky Morton Sep 21st
- Connor Jones Sep 21st
- Mike Chacoma Sep 22nd
- Red River Brawler Sep 22nd
- Doug Somers Sep 22nd
- Satine Sep 22nd
- Harley D Sep 22nd
- Rocco Valentino Sep 23rd
- O'Malley Sep 23rd
- Cole Crittenden Sep 23rd
- Joe Jones Sep 24th
- Len Rossi Sep 24th
- Connor Crunk Sep 24th
- Clayton Bloodstone Sep 24th
- Kai Fayden Sep 24th
- John J. Bishop Sep 24th
- Jason Bruce Sep 24th
- Chief Mike Sep 25th
- Jimmy Garvin Sep 25th
- Toots Estes Sep 25th
- Angel [2nd] Sep 25th
- Clifton Clinstock Sep 26th
- BB Sep 26th
- Lone Eagle Sep 26th
- Kendo Nagasaki Sep 26th
- Chris Matthews Sep 26th
- Ka$haNova Sep 26th
- Jhamil O$Neal Sep 26th
Current Champions
Unified Wrestling of Oklahoma
Dojo Division Champion
Cole Lung
- Heavyweight Champion: Malik Mayfield
- Women's Champion: Shylynn