Review of Guest Booker DVD with Dutch Mantell
Posted: Dec 9th 2010 By: CMBurnham
January 2010 was supposed to change things for the better in TNA Wrestling. Previous months saw TNA President Dixie Carter hold a press conference at Madison Square Garden where it was announced the legend of Hulk Hogan and the former WCW creative mind Eric Bischoff were joining the promotion. TNA founder Jeff Jarrett ran into some personal issues that took him off TV and away from Orlando. In addition the promotion was moving from their Thursday night slot on Spike TV to go head-to-head with the WWE and its perennial Monday Night Raw show. In the process TNA?s creative team was shaken up and Dutch Mantell was given his release. The next few months saw TNA fall flat on their face and have to rethink things. Guest Booker host Sean Oliver and his crew decided to allow TNA to hit the reset button, but do it with Mr. Mantell in charge of the creative direction.
In the booking topic Mantell give his creative philosophy that brought him success in Memphis & Puerto Rico plus how the experience of being a wrestler helped shape his writing style. Mantell said after he picked his ?team to send on the field,? he used to listen to the live crowd to gauge what was successful and what went into the trash bin. Mr. Mantell says the old territorial days (where 32 existed in the US) were great for a wrestler so they wouldn?t burn out their character in one promotion. The topic moves to the horrible night that Frank ?Bruiser Brody? Goodish was stabbed to death in Puerto Rico. Mantell was Goodish?s travel partner in Puerto Rico and was there in the locker room moments before the stabbing.
Dutch moves onto how Jeff Jarrett got him to join TNA Wrestling during its weekly PPV days in Nashville, TN while he was still booking in Puerto Rico. The stories of the creative process with Jeff and Vince Russo are worth the price of admission. Sean does address Dixie Carter?s comments that were made on her YouShoot DVD on how she handled the ?fire Russo? live event chants and Dutch?s answer is priceless. Dutch also addresses the white hot personal issues between Jim Cornette and Russo plus what he expected when Hogan/Bischoff were signed by the promotion. If you were expecting an answer to why he was let go you will not be finding it here but he does feel he might have been a scapegoat for certain things.
This is an excellent DVD except the overall product is called Guest Booker and Mr. Mantell spends roughly 30-40 minutes doing the actual booking. Now before you send me hate mail (radio@onlineworldofwrestling.com) I would have enjoyed this DVD if it was just Dutch speaking about his time as part of TNA creative. This DVD unfortunately followed the same road as Mike Graham?s appearance on the Guest Booker series. However Dutch is far more entertaining and more experience as a booker than Mr. Graham. I was kind of hoping this would have followed the Gabe Sapolsky DVD where he opened his ROH booking notebook to show what he had planned before his departure. You can find his book ?The World According to Dutch? on www.amazon.com. Log onto his Facebook page for news on his new book ?Tales From a Dirt Road.?
The next releases listed on www.kayfabecommentaries.com are Ring Roast III with Jim Cornette, YouShoot with the Iron Sheik and Timeline History of the WWE 2001 with Lisa ?Ivory? Moretti.
If you sent in questions for the two Jim Cornette YouShoot DVD?s but didn?t get it asked by Sean Oliver, send it to radio@onlineworldofwrestling.com before Monday December 13th. We will be pre-taping an interview with Mr. Cornette that will air on December 14th edition of Online World of Wrestling Radio.
Supplemental Information
Spotlight in History
- 1983 Magnum T. A. & Jim Duggan def. Ted DiBiase & Mr. Olympia for the MSW Mid-South Tag Team Titles
- 2005 Brandon Groom & American Anarchy became the NWA-U Oklahoma Tag Team Champions
- 2010 The Hardcore Connection (Maniac Mike & Shane Sanchez) def. X-Rated (Bobby Star & Kevin James Sanchez) for the SWCW Tag Team Titles
- 2010 Kareem Sadat became the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 2010 Brandon Walker def. Jonathan Cross for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 2010 Jonathan Cross def. Brandon Walker for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 2019 Antonio Vega def. Shawn Sanders for the ASP Inter-County Title
- 2020 Derek James def. Alex Royal for the BPW Oklahoma Title
- 2020 Size Matters (Sam Stackhouse & Mike Starr) def. Legend Has It (Thrash & Killbane) for the BPW Oklahoma Tag Team Titles
- 2020 Ethan Cole def. Tommy Dean for the BPW Lion Heart Title
- 2022 Sam Stackhouse became the WCR Heavyweight Champion
Week of Sun 07-19 to Sat: 07-25
- 07-19 1968 Fritz Von Erich & Grizzly Smith def. The Spoiler & Gary Hart for the WCCW American Tag Team Titles
- 07-19 1968 Jack Dalton [1st] & Jim Dalton became the TSW Louisiana Tag Team Champions
- 07-19 1971 Thunderbolt Patterson & Toru Tanaka def. Johnny Valentine & Wahoo McDaniel for the WCCW American Tag Team Titles
- 07-19 1982 Bill Irwin def. Brian Adias for the WCCW Television Title
- 07-19 2008 Dane Griffin def. Les Mayne for the 3DW Texoma Title
- 07-19 2013 Big Daddy Moore became the BPPW Heavyweight Champion
- 07-19 2019 Shawn Sanders became the ASP Inter-County Champion
- 07-19 2019 Xavior def. Paul Puertorico for the MSWA Mid-South Heavyweight Title
- 07-19 2019 Team Boner (Drake Gallows & Mascara La Parka) became the MSWA Mid-South Tag Team Champions
- 07-19 2024 Father Padge became the MajCW Heavyweight Champion
- 07-19 2024 Brandon Warhawk became the MajCW Flawless Champion
- 07-19 2024 Hell's Kitchen (The Canadian Red Devil & The Lunchador) became the MajCW Tag Team Champions
- 07-19 2024 Lunchador became the MajCW 24/7 On Call Champion
- 07-19 2024 Nightwolf became the MajCW Native American Champion
- 07-19 2024 Cardinal Sin def. Lunchador for the MajCW 24/7 On Call Title
- 07-19 2024 Jason Simon/Bishop Simon def. Nightwolf for the MajCW Native American Title
- 07-19 2024 Deacon Hendrix def. Cardinal Sin for the MajCW 24/7 On Call Title
- 07-19 2024 Tyler Shade def. Deacon Hendrix for the MajCW 24/7 On Call Title
- 07-20 1961 Waldo Von Erich def. Tony Martin for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 07-20 1979 Gino Hernandez & El Gran Markus def. Jose Lothario & El Halcon for the WCCW American Tag Team Titles
- 07-20 1986 Eddie Gilbert & Sting def. The Fantastics (Tommy Rogers & Bobby Fulton) for the UWF Tag Team Titles
- 07-20 2008 The Forsaken (Michael Faith & Halo) def. Limited Edition (Les Mayne & Dane Griffin) for the MSWA Mid-South Tag Team Titles
- 07-20 2013 Drake Gallows became the IZW Impact Division Champion
- 07-20 2013 Kareem Sadat became the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 07-20 2014 The K. C. Wolves (Graham Bell & Luke Langley) became the WFC Tag Team Champions
- 07-20 2018 Double D def. Colby Black for the MSWA eXpress Title
- 07-20 2026 Vincent Cross def. Bang Bang Bennett for the RDW Na'Cho Momma's Hardcore Title
- 07-21 1947 Buddy Rogers def. Dale Levin for the NWA Midwest World Title
- 07-21 1979 Bill Watts & Buck Robley def. The Assassin & The Angel [1st] for the TSW United States Tag Team Titles
- 07-21 2012 The Mercenary became the UWE United States Champion
- 07-21 2012 L. J. McDaniels became the SWCW Womens Champion
- 07-21 2012 Sam Stackhouse def. Jake O'Brien for the SRPW Heavyweight Title
- 07-21 2012 Angel Blue def. Venus for the IZW Queens Title
- 07-21 2018 Drake Gallows def. Alex Royal for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 07-21 2018 Alex Royal def. Drake Gallows for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 07-22 1959 Danny McShain def. The Zebra Kid for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 07-22 1960 Danny Hodge def. Angelo Savoldi for the NWA World Junior Heavyweight Title
- 07-22 1979 Mark Lewin def. Bruiser Brody for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 07-22 1981 Bob Roop def. Super Destroyer for the MSW Louisiana Title
- 07-22 1985 Butch Reed def. Dutch Mantell for the MSW Television Title
- 07-22 2012 Cody Jones def. Les Mayne for the MSWA Oklahoma Title
- 07-22 2016 Nathan Estrada def. Adrian Dell for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Title
- 07-22 2016 Steven Cruze def. Seth Angel for the ComPro Showtime Title
- 07-22 2017 Future Hall of Famers/Impact, Inc. (Johnny Z & Damien Morte & Jermaine Johnson) became the IZW Tag Team Champions
- 07-22 2017 Ryan Davidson def. Aaron Anders for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Title
- 07-22 2017 Aaron Anders def. Brian Breaker for the ComPro Heavyweight Title
- 07-22 2017 Wesley Crane def. Skyler Fayden for the UWE United States Title
- 07-22 2023 Tyler Midas def. The Lunchador for the WAH Hunger Dojo Title
- 07-23 1967 Karl Kox def. Waldo Von Erich for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 07-23 1979 Kerry Von Erich & Bruiser Brody became the WCCW Texas Tag Team Champions
- 07-23 2004 Rocco Valentino def. Justin Lee for the TPW Oklahoma Heavyweight Title
- 07-23 2005 Tyler Bateman def. John O'Malley for the MSWA Tri-State Title
- 07-23 2011 John E. Stone def. Kevin James Sanchez for the SWCW Heavyweight Title
- 07-23 2011 Double D def. Michael Barry for the IZW Impact Division Title
- 07-23 2011 Teila & El Hoto Loco def. Chris Von Luhr & Jason Noal for the ACW Tag Team Titles
- 07-23 2011 Chris Von Luhr & Jason Noal def. Teila & El Hoto Loco for the ACW Tag Team Titles
- 07-23 2021 Ky-Ote def. Dane Griffin for the TexPro Oklahoma Title
- 07-23 2026 MLP def. Vincent Cross for the RDW Na'Cho Momma's Hardcore Title
- 07-23 2026 Bang Bang Bennett def. MLP for the RDW Na'Cho Momma's Hardcore Title
- 07-23 2026 Vincent Cross def. Bang Bang Bennett for the RDW Na'Cho Momma's Hardcore Title
- 07-24 1983 Magnum T. A. & Jim Duggan def. Ted DiBiase & Mr. Olympia for the MSW Mid-South Tag Team Titles
- 07-24 2005 Brandon Groom & American Anarchy became the NWA-U Oklahoma Tag Team Champions
- 07-24 2010 The Hardcore Connection (Maniac Mike & Shane Sanchez) def. X-Rated (Bobby Star & Kevin James Sanchez) for the SWCW Tag Team Titles
- 07-24 2010 Kareem Sadat became the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 07-24 2010 Brandon Walker def. Jonathan Cross for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 07-24 2010 Jonathan Cross def. Brandon Walker for the UWE Heavyweight Title
- 07-24 2019 Antonio Vega def. Shawn Sanders for the ASP Inter-County Title
- 07-24 2020 Derek James def. Alex Royal for the BPW Oklahoma Title
- 07-24 2020 Size Matters (Sam Stackhouse & Mike Starr) def. Legend Has It (Thrash & Killbane) for the BPW Oklahoma Tag Team Titles
- 07-24 2020 Ethan Cole def. Tommy Dean for the BPW Lion Heart Title
- 07-24 2022 Sam Stackhouse became the WCR Heavyweight Champion
- 07-25 1957 Duke Keomuka def. Bull Curry for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 07-25 1962 Hiro Matsuda & Don Kent def. Alberto Torres & Ramon Torres for the TSW United States Tag Team Titles
- 07-25 1966 Tony Borne def. Louie Tillet for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Title
- 07-25 1977 Captain USA def. Bruiser Brody for the WCCW American Heavyweight Title
- 07-25 1980 Ken Mantell became the MSW Louisiana Champion
- 07-25 1981 Eddie Gilbert & Ricky Morton def. Ed Wiskowski & Mike George for the TSW Tag Team Titles
- 07-25 1983 Jimmy Garvin def. Kevin Von Erich for the WCCW American Heavyweight Title
- 07-25 1988 The Simpson Brothers (Steve Simpson & Shaun Simpson) def. John Tatum & Jack Victory for the WCCW Texas Tag Team Titles
- 07-25 2009 Team SuperBad (El Super Colibri & Justin Lee) def. Crazy Beautiful (Brett Taylor & Michael York) for the ComPro Tag Team Titles
- 07-25 2015 La Famiglia (Luke Grayson & Thomas Knight) def. Seth Angel & Adrian Dell for the ComPro Tag Team Titles
- 07-25 2020 Real Dirty Brawlers (Brawler Morrison & Thrash) def. Tommy Dean for the WFC Tag Team Titles
- 07-25 2020 Jon Cross def. Luke Langley for the WFC Hometown Heroes Title
- 07-25 2020 Tim Rockwell def. Jon Cross for the WFC Hometown Heroes Title
- 07-25 2021 Thrash def. Luke Savage for the ASP Mid-American Title
- Original Oklahoma Outlaw Jul 24th Today!
- Anthony Wild Jul 24th Today!
- Skip Young Jul 24th Today!
- Joe Savoldi Jul 24th Today!
- Jack Gamble Jul 25th
- Pastor Brent Jul 25th
- Kevin Morgan Jul 25th
- Norman Charles Jul 25th
- Red River Jack [2nd] Jul 25th
- Yali Sapphire Jul 25th
- Athan Sorrow Jul 25th
- Lee Cook Jul 26th
- Mike Bytheway Jul 26th
- Jack Van Bebber Jul 27th
- T. J. Muniz Jul 27th
- Nova Phoenix Jul 27th
- Matt Borne Jul 27th
- Eric Rose Jul 27th
- Johnny Idol Jul 27th
- Tom Simon Jul 27th
- Brixton Barricade Jul 28th
- Sammy Guevara Jul 28th
- Tim Woods Jul 28th
- Butch Malone Jul 28th
- Herb Calvert Jul 28th
- Luke Brown Jul 28th
- Brian Lakewood Jul 28th
- Dan Webber Jul 29th
- Oliver John Jul 29th
- Betty Boucher Jul 29th
- Boss Campbell Jul 29th
- Antonio Vega Jul 29th
- Billy Starr Jul 29th
- Scott Steiner Jul 29th
- Bobby Whitlock Jul 29th
- Ace Archuleta Jul 29th
- Derek James Jul 30th
- Trey Bearhill Jul 31st
- Kid Kash Jul 31st
- Floyd Maystorm Jul 31st
- Wayne Black Jul 31st
- Dale Robinson Aug 1st
- Eric the Red Aug 1st
- Everett Rattan Aug 1st
- Jimmy Golden Aug 1st
- Joel Deaton Aug 1st
- Amanda Barricade Aug 2nd
- Tim Rockwell Aug 2nd
- Jack Vaughn Aug 2nd
- Gorgeous George, Jr. Aug 2nd
- Capt. Rowdy Aug 2nd
- Bull Ramos Aug 3rd
- Haystacks Calhoun Aug 3rd
- Altar Boy Sanchez Aug 3rd
- Karl Gotch Aug 3rd
- Ronnie Morton Aug 3rd
- Ellis Bashara Aug 4th
- Tyson Jaymes Aug 4th
- Alaskan Aug 4th
- Stormi Renee Aug 4th
- Roy Dunn Aug 4th
- Stan Lane Aug 5th
- Glen Steel Aug 5th
- Jimmy Valiant Aug 6th
- Grizzly Smith Aug 6th
- Samedi Aug 6th
- Timothy Johnston Aug 6th
Most Active Members
- Striker
- Michael York
- The Mayne Event
- cphs_sweethearts
- Talon