Federal Court rules on Warrior vs McMahon case
Posted: Oct 15th 2007 By: mikeiles
It has been ruled by The United States Federal District Court of Arizona that the complaint filed by Ultimate Creations, Inc. against Vince McMahon; Titan Sports; and the WWE will not be dismissed and will go to trial.
"To survive the motion to dismiss his defamation claims, Warrior must establish that the statements 'are reasonably capable of sustaining a defamatory meaning,' and that the statements 'are not mere comment within the ambit of the First Amendment.' Knievel v. ESPN, 393 F.3d 1068, 1073-74 (9th Cir. 2005) (quotations omitted). Defendants believe that Warrior has failed to establish either of these requirements. The Court does not agree. After examining the totality of the circumstances in which the Defendants statements were made, the Court finds that Defendants allegedly made statements about Warrior that can be reasonably interpreted as factual assertions that may have brought him 'into disrepute, contempt, or ridicule' or
impeached his 'honesty, integrity, virtue, or reputation.' Consequently, Warrior?s claims against Vince and Linda McMahon will not be dismissed."
In a statement made by Bernie J. Gernay of PSI Marketing Group whom represents Warrior, he stated, "There is no denying the legitimacy of this complaint, just as there's also no denying that there is the illegitimate, choreographed world of professional wrestling and then there is the legitimate rule of law in the real world. Warrior lives in the real world. WWE and the McMahons apparently do not. Warrior has made another successful, 'constructive,' not 'self-destructive,' life
outside his former successes creating and performing the one-of-a-kind Ultimate Warrior character. The McMahons seem to have problems with that, both acknowledging it and letting it go. They can run their company any way they wish to, but they have no right to discredit the integrity or try to ruin the life of any former talent who chooses to no longer be a part of their entertainment act, let alone do so as they have outrageously seen fit to do in this instance,
through a film project that both defames my client and obscenely profit. They can script their characters in provocative storylines where common sense, decency and justice may never prevail, but none of that will play very well inside a real court room in the real world before a jury of real people. My client looks forward to that day."
Supplemental Information
Latest News
OG Seeka Represents His People at Prison Show
They say you can't go home again. And while Montego Seeka may not have ever called Harp Correctional Centre in Lexingto... Read More
If You’re Not the Local You Must be….an Express
In wrestling history there have been no less than 180+ teams that have used “Express” in their title. From the ... Read More
EC3 Opens Up About His Time In WWE, Being NWA Champion, What’s Next For Him, More
In the latest exclusive interview with PWMania’s Scott Mitchell (@Scott44Mitchell), E... Read More
Spotlight in History
- 1969 Jose Lothario def. Johnny Valentine for the WCCW Texas Heavyweight Champion
- 2008 Ky-ote Johammed def. Dane Griffin for the 3DW Violent Division Champion
- 2008 Mo'Body Gillespie def. Ky-ote Johammed for the 3DW Violent Division Champion
- 2013 Bobby Starr def. Steven Sterling for the ComPro Showtime Champion
- 2013 Ignition def. Super Skunk Ape, Jr. for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Champion
- 2013 The Canadian Red Devil def. Michael York for the ComPro Heavyweight Champion
- 2014 Steven Sterling def. Sam Stackhouse for the ComPro Showtime Champion
- 2014 Jake O'Brien def. The Canadian Red Devil for the ComPro Heavyweight Champion
- 2014 Terry Montana def. Ignition for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Champion
- 2014 Havoc def. Buster Cherry for the SWCW All-American Champion
- 2014 Rick Russo def. David Kyzer for the SWCW Luchadore Champion
- 2014 Kevin James Sanchez def. Kareem Sadat for the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 2014 Kareem Sadat def. Kevin James Sanchez for the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 2014 Terry Pantera became the BPPW Junior Heavyweight Champion
Week of Sun 06-02 to Sat: 06-08
- 06-02 1979 The Spoiler became the WCCW American Heavyweight Champion
- 06-02 2007 Damien Morte def. Kareem Sadat for the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 06-02 2007 Lady Venom became the SWCW Womens Champion
- 06-02 2007 Prophet def. Dexter Hardaway for the SWCW Sooner Xtreme Champion
- 06-02 2010 Michael Barry def. Kevin James Sanchez for the BYEW Heavyweight Champion
- 06-02 2010 Saints of the Damned (Draven Cross & Sage) def. New Canada (The Canadian Red Devil & The Canadian Luchadore) for the BYEW Tag Team Champion
- 06-02 2010 Death Row [2nd] def. Rick Russo for the BYEW Caution Champion
- 06-02 2012 Brandon Walker became the UWE Heavyweight Champion
- 06-02 2012 The Syndicate (Scott Sanders & Shawn Sanders) def. The Franchise Players (Rick Russo & Les Mayne) for the SWCW Tag Team Champions
- 06-02 2012 Drake Gallows def. Kareem Sadat for the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 06-02 2017 Cody Burns def. Brandon Groom for the BPPW Oklahoma Champion
- 06-02 2019 Team Boner (Drake Gallows & Mascara La Parka/MLP) def. The Saints of Pro Wrestling (Scott Sanders & Shawn Sanders) for the ASP Tag Team Champions
- 06-02 2019 Brock Landers def. Adam Patrick for the ASP Inter-County Champion
- 06-02 2019 Erica became the ASP Women's Champion
- 06-02 2024 Toxic Masculinity (Johnny Lightning & Johnny Dynamite) def. Mr. Nasty & Eddie LeVaughn for the WFC Tag Team Champions
- 06-02 2024 Thrash def. Tim Rockwell for the WFC Heavyweight Champion
- 06-03 1968 Fritz Von Erich def. Spoiler #1 for the WCCW American Heavyweight Champion
- 06-03 1968 Danny Hodge & Lorenzo Parente def. Jack Donovan & Ron Reed for the TSW United States Tag Team Champion
- 06-03 1969 Baron Von Raschke became the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Champion
- 06-03 1980 David Von Erich def. Gino Hernandez for the WCCW Texas Heavyweight Champion
- 06-03 2016 Brock Landers def. Terry Pantera for the MSWA Oklahoma Champion
- 06-03 2016 C. J. Ward became the MSWA Mid-South Cruiserweight Champion
- 06-03 2017 The Pinnacle (Anthony Andrews & Shawn Hendrix) def. Excellence Personified (Dustin Heritage & Duke Swellington) for the ComPro Tag Team Champions
- 06-04 1937 Ray Villmer became the TSW Missouri Junior Heavyweight Champion
- 06-04 1981 Kerry Von Erich def. Ernie Ladd for the WCCW American Heavyweight Champion
- 06-04 1981 The Spoiler became the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Champion
- 06-04 1984 Gino Hernandez def. Chris Adams for the WCCW Texas Brass Knuckles Champion
- 06-04 1986 The Von Erichs (Kevin Von Erich & Lance Von Erich & Mike Von Erich) became the WCCW World 6-Man Tag Team Champion
- 06-04 2002 Billy & Chuck def. Rikishi & Rico for the WWE RAW World Tag Team Champion
- 06-04 2004 Justin Lee def. Brian Lakewood for the TPW Oklahoma Heavyweight Champion
- 06-04 2010 The Foreign Legion (Boris Saarikoski & Dutch Hagen) def. The Old School Express (Jason Jones & Jake Boulder) for the MWA Tag Team Champions
- 06-04 2021 Warren Powers def. Father Padge for the EPW Internet Television Champion
- 06-04 2022 Tommy Dean def. Mr. Nasty for the CPW Heavyweight Champion
- 06-04 2022 Phoebe def. Killista for the CPW Women’s Champion
- 06-04 2022 Mascara Purpura def. Double D for the CPW 918 Champion
- 06-05 1975 Dick Murdoch def. Danny Miller for the TSW North American Champion
- 06-05 1997 Generation X (Zane Morris & Ian St. James) became the OPW Oklahoma Tag Team Champion
- 06-05 2009 El Super Colibri became the MWA MAX-Division Champion
- 06-05 2010 Rick Russo def. 3rd Rail for the SWCW Heavyweight Champion
- 06-05 2021 Two Man Sam (Sam Stackhouse & Samuel Savage) became the CPW Tag Team Champions
- 06-05 2021 Tommy Dean def. Double D for the CPW Heavyweight Champion
- 06-06 1966 Fritz Von Erich def. Brute Bernard for the WCCW American Heavyweight Champion
- 06-06 1972 Tom Jones & Ivan Putski def. The Continental Warriors (Bobby Hart & Lorenzo Parente) for the TSW United States Tag Team Champion
- 06-06 1981 Jake Roberts def. The Grappler for the MSW North American Heavyweight Champion
- 06-07 1969 Jose Lothario def. Johnny Valentine for the WCCW Texas Heavyweight Champion
- 06-07 2008 Ky-ote Johammed def. Dane Griffin for the 3DW Violent Division Champion
- 06-07 2008 Mo'Body Gillespie def. Ky-ote Johammed for the 3DW Violent Division Champion
- 06-07 2013 Bobby Starr def. Steven Sterling for the ComPro Showtime Champion
- 06-07 2013 Ignition def. Super Skunk Ape, Jr. for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Champion
- 06-07 2013 The Canadian Red Devil def. Michael York for the ComPro Heavyweight Champion
- 06-07 2014 Steven Sterling def. Sam Stackhouse for the ComPro Showtime Champion
- 06-07 2014 Jake O'Brien def. The Canadian Red Devil for the ComPro Heavyweight Champion
- 06-07 2014 Terry Montana def. Ignition for the ComPro Oklahoma X Division Champion
- 06-07 2014 Havoc def. Buster Cherry for the SWCW All-American Champion
- 06-07 2014 Rick Russo def. David Kyzer for the SWCW Luchadore Champion
- 06-07 2014 Kevin James Sanchez def. Kareem Sadat for the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 06-07 2014 Kareem Sadat def. Kevin James Sanchez for the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 06-07 2014 Terry Pantera became the BPPW Junior Heavyweight Champion
- 06-08 1959 Frankie Kovacs & Jerry Miller def. Pretty Boy Collins & Duke Scarbo for the TSW Louisiana Tag Team Champion
- 06-08 2013 L. J. McDaniels became the SWCW Hardcore Champion
- 06-08 2013 Hurricane Ross def. Billy Ray for the NAW Heavyweight Champion
- 06-08 2019 Michael Duplanti def. Anarchy [2nd] for the NAW Lightweight Champion
- 06-08 2019 Big Smooth def. Hurricane Ross for the NAW Heavyweight Champion
- Morgan Levay Jun 7th Today!
- Stevie Caballero Jun 7th Today!
- Mick Foley Jun 7th Today!
- Eddie Sullivan Jun 7th Today!
- Gideon Vane Jun 7th Today!
- Steve Hartley Jun 7th Today!
- Michele Leone Jun 8th
- Rick Vyper Jun 8th
- Mustafa Bin Akbar Jun 8th
- Jim Barnett Jun 9th
- Jamie Jun 9th
- Dutch Savage Jun 9th
- Mark Wilson Jun 9th
- Dick Listener Jun 9th
- Jeff Wolfenbarger Jun 9th
- Largus RagnaBrok Jun 10th
- Dick Dunn Jun 10th
- J. D. Richards Jun 11th
- Mathmagician Jun 11th
- Magnum T. A. Jun 11th
- King Parsons Jun 11th
- Stan Pulaski Jun 12th
- Baby Blimp Jun 12th
- Lady Sensacion Jun 12th
- Deuce Rodriguez Jun 12th
- Zac Royal Jun 12th
- Steven Dane Jun 12th
- D'Licious Jun 12th
- Rolling Thunder Jun 12th
- Chandler Hopkins Jun 13th
- Bill Ash Jun 13th
- Mikey D Jun 13th
- John Pfanz Jun 13th
- Dustin Heritage Jun 13th
- Geronimo Jun 13th
- Neo Genesis Jun 13th
- Buzz Sawyer Jun 14th
- Jaxon Stone Jun 15th
- Sean Ryan Jun 15th
- Trey the Bae Jun 15th
- Lilith Grimm Jun 15th
- Paul Linam Jun 15th
- Brad Armstrong Jun 15th
- Paul Jones Jun 16th
- Shawn Matthews III Jun 16th
- Ultimate Warrior Jun 16th
- Chuck Hinds Jun 16th
- Brock Landers Jun 16th
- Ted Arcidi Jun 16th
- Jef Tiger Jun 16th
- Ray Martinez Jun 17th
- Rob Justice Jun 17th
- Talos Jun 17th
- Mario Galento Jun 17th
- Cam the CODA Jun 18th
- Bruiser Brody Jun 18th
- Bad Boy Jun 18th
- Andy Dalton Jun 18th
- Sashimi Deluxe Jun 18th
- Abe Jacobs Jun 18th
- Johnny Angel Jun 18th
- Canadian Red Devil Jun 19th
- Miguel Padilla Jun 19th
- Top Dollar Bill Jun 19th
- Kodi Ocean Jun 19th
- Mike Two Jun 19th
- Wahoo McDaniel Jun 19th
- Billy the Kid Jun 19th
- Jon Cross Jun 20th
- Koko B. Ware Jun 20th
- Professor Ito Jun 20th
- David Kyzer Jun 20th
Most Active Members
- Striker
- Michael York
- The Mayne Event
- cphs_sweethearts
- Talon
